PreviousNext
Page 136
Previous/Next Page
Witness to the History of Australian MedicineWitness to the History of Australian Medicine
----------
Table of Contents

Tobacco Control: Australia's Role

Transcript of Witness Seminar

Introduction

Building the case for tobacco control

Producing, and Responding to, the Evidence

Campaigning for Tobacco Control

Economic Initiatives in Tobacco Control

The Radical Wing of Tobacco Control

Revolutionary Road

Tobacco Industry Strategies and Responses to Them

Campaign Evaluation

Managing Difficulties in Light of Community Consensus

Radical Wing Again

The Process of Political Change

Tobacco Campaigns Up Close

A Speedier Pace of Change

Political Needs and Campaign Strategies

Litigation and its Impacts

Insights from Tobacco Control

Tobacco Control in Australia in International Perspective

Appendix 1: Statement by Anne Jones

Endnotes

Index
Search
Help

Contact us
The Radical Wing of Tobacco Control

Ann Westmore: John said the strength of the idea is crucial, and also presumably making the most of those opportunities when you can talk one-to-one with a politician. Are there others here who have had that experience?

Simon Chapman: I think the idea, and the killer facts that strengthen the evidence, are critical. But I think there’s a step we’ve left out as well.

I think a lot of this was down to B.U.G.A. U.P.[58] in the late 1980s. What I noticed myself was that in the pre-B.U.G.A. U.P. period of my tobacco involvement if in social situations you said to people that you worked in the tobacco control area – well, you didn’t use that expression for a start, it was anti-smoking – they’d move away from you. At parties, they’d expect you to turn the music down and wouldn’t expect you to have a second drink.

After B.U.G.A. U.P., it brought ‘small l’ liberals and lefties into the picture. It also started to slowly radicalise, that’s probably the wrong word, energise conservative medical groups like the AMA[59] who’d done nothing up to that point other than to say we need more information. And then the Colleges[60] and the AMA started including legislative reforms in their submissions.

I think there was a cultural shift brought about by the undeniable humour and hard-hitting political messages of B.U.G.A. U.P. which was active mainly in NSW, Victoria, and WA.

Harley Stanton: I was going through some of my files and I have some of these MOP UP newsletters from the early 1980s in Victoria. I don’t know who started that here.

Simon Chapman: We started a group called MOP UP. Our main claim to fame was that we got Paul Hogan[61] out of Winfield advertising. We wrote repeatedly to the Advertising Standards Council and eventually we had a hearing under Sir Richard Kirby, the Chairman of the Industrial Relations Commission. He basically agreed with us and Hogan went.

Members of B.U.G.A. U.P. came to our first meeting. They were anarchist-kind of guys who said, ‘All this letter-writing stuff is great. You do that and this is what we’re going to do.’ You can now see their work catalogued on a fantastic web-site.[62]

They started off as a bunch of bearded anarchist types and then professionals started getting involved. People like Jo Cavanagh down here, and Andy Zdenkowski, a GP in Newcastle who got arrested.

Garry Egger: Initially B.U.G.A. U.P. was just defacing billboards. Then Phil Rubinstein,[63] the ex-advertising guy, talked to them and said, ‘You’ve got to make the message mean something. Change what they’re saying to something that’s negative.’

David Hill: It was very helpful to have some of these doctors among the ranks of B.U.G.A. U.P., especially when they came before magistrates in the courts. One of them in Victoria was a leading plastic surgeon, John Anstee[64] who’d been mentored by the iconic Benny Rank.[65]

Simon Chapman: In the very early days of B.U.G.A. U.P. I used to get all sorts of messages along the lines of ‘You’ve got to stop this. It’s going to ruin everything’. But soon that message changed quite quickly to ‘This is fantastic. You’ve got to do more of this.’


Previous Page Witness to the History of Australian Medicine Next Page


© The University of Melbourne 2005-16
Published by eScholarship Research Centre, using the Web Academic Resource Publisher
http://witness.esrc.unimelb.edu.au/136.html